Vaccine-Injury Reports Returned as “Coincidences”¶
Day 2 · 8:16:42 · Dean Allison · Charles Hoffe
- 📋 Law required reporting; top safety official Monica Naus declared his cases coincidences without examining patients.
- 📬 After registered-mail resubmission of laborious nine-page reports, all 14 were returned as not vaccine injuries.
- 🔇 Public health never requested charts or spoke to him; advice was “don’t tell them it’s a vaccine injury.”
Mandatory reports dismissed without investigation while officials denied harm publicly.
← Gag Orders, Open Letter to Bonnie Henry, and College Threats | College Charges Dropped After Failed Judicial-Notice Trap →
Transcript¶
Dean Allison · 8:16:42
So on that point, you, um, because actually by law in Canada you are obligated to report what you believe is a vaccine injury.
Charles Hoffe · 8:16:51
Correct.
Dean Allison · 8:16:52
So by law, you've got this obligation.
Charles Hoffe · 8:16:55
Yes.
Dean Allison · 8:16:56
You have a number of vaccine who you believe are vaccine injured patients.
Charles Hoffe · 8:17:00
Yeah.
Dean Allison · 8:17:00
So do you follow the law and submit vaccine injury reports?
Charles Hoffe · 8:17:04
Well, I did, and I tried. So, so the other response to that letter was Dr. Bonnie Henry. She never replied to it, but, but she, she referred this to her top vaccine safety specialist, who was Dr. Monica Naus. So I was offered—.
Dean Allison · 8:17:19
Dr. Monica?
Charles Hoffe · 8:17:20
Monica Naus, N-A-U-S. So I was offered a telephone meeting with her. And at that meeting, I explained to her what I've seen as a family doctor, what's happening to my patients. And her response was to assure me that these were not vaccine injuries. Now, she hadn't seen or assessed any of my patients in any way. But yet she said, these are not vaccine injuries. These must be all coincidences. And I said, well, I don't know what to do. I don't know how to treat this. I don't know what the diagnosis is. I've tried these 3 hospitals, 3 neurology departments in major referral hospitals. No one will touch this with a 10-foot pole. Please, will you help me to find a neurologist who will assess these patients urgently? And she said, no, I can't. I can't do that. So I said, well, how do I get somebody to see them? How do I get a specialist to assess these patients? She said, don't tell them it's a vaccine injury.
Charles Hoffe · 8:18:21
Those were her words.
Dean Allison · 8:18:25
Now, what happened to the vaccine injury reports that you filed?
Charles Hoffe · 8:18:29
So I started submitting these reports, and the first— after I'd sent the first 6, They were— this regional health officer, not Dr. Bonnie Henry, but the regional one that I was told to direct my questions to, was having press conferences and things saying that what I was saying was untrue, that there was no vaccine injuries, that what I was claiming as vaccine injuries was completely unfounded, again, without investigating any of the things that I was trying to report. And so I assumed, well, okay, let's give her the benefit of the doubt. Maybe she's never got the 6 vaccine injury reports that I've submitted. So then I redid them all, and each one is 9 pages. It's a laborious— I figured I'd probably take you 25 minutes to do each one, and you get paid zero. So, you know, so anyway, I then started sending them by registered mail so that somebody had to sign for them so that they couldn't say they didn't get them. And after I'd sent 14 and every single one was returned to me saying, look, these are not vaccine injuries, these are all coincidences.
Dean Allison · 8:19:36
So, so there were real responses then when you sent them registered mail?
Charles Hoffe · 8:19:41
Yes, they then, they then responded and told me they weren't vaccine injuries.
Dean Allison · 8:19:46
And I, I just want everyone to totally understand, so you've been the doctor of these patients at this point for like It's 28 years. 28 Years. Um, you've got their medical charts, you've got this history, you've, you're, you're, they're coming to you, you're examining them. Did this anyone from this office ask for a single patient's charts?
Charles Hoffe · 8:20:08
No, no, I never got a phone call. They, they never spoke to, they wouldn't speak to me.
Dean Allison · 8:20:13
And they didn't speak to your patients?
Charles Hoffe · 8:20:16
Well, I asked some of them, some of them said a nurse A nurse phoned them. But, you know, these were people who should have been assessed by a neurologist.
Dean Allison · 8:20:27
And one of who was admitted into the hospital once they were.
Charles Hoffe · 8:20:30
Well, yeah, yeah. Well, I mean, so, but that was, so in other words, public health that were rolling this out, when you're rolling out a new experimental treatment, you should be monitoring it very carefully. There was no follow-up. There was— all there was was a denial that it could possibly do harm. And so—.
Dean Allison · 8:20:52
And then I've just got two quick things because we're running out of time.